Cleaning Service

Which is Best – Tile vs Shingle Roof

residential roofing companies

Whether you are building a new home or remodeling your current home, selecting the right roofing material is an essential component you will want to get right. You have to be very careful about this important decision because an average home usually requires a roof overhaul after almost every 25-50 years. However, there are two of the most popular types of roofing materials out there. 

Roof installation is a huge investment for a homeowner, and it is definitely not the one to be taken lightly. It is because the roof is one of the essential parts of the home’s exterior. It protects your home from the exterior elements and adds appearance and curb appeal. Besides, a well-maintained roof says a lot about your home.

If you are getting ready to replace your existing roof, you must be considering tile vs shingle roof because these are two of the most frequently used materials for the roof. Both of these are attractive, durable, and provide aesthetic appeal. Then how are you supposed to know which is the best? Both have positive and negative aspects. Here in this post, you will find out the pros, cons, and differences between these two most popular roofing materials. 

Tile Roof

Though most US homes have shingles, if you compare tile vs shingle roof on a global level, you will find that tile roofing is more popular worldwide. Tile has been in use for over a century, even before the modern asphalt shingles. Here are the pros and cons of tile roofing.


  • Durable
  • Long-lasting
  • Eco-friendly
  • Low-maintenance
  • Versatile
  • Many styles available
  • Enhance resale value


  • May crack
  • Expensive
  • Prone to moss growth
  • Not suitable for every climate
  • Difficult to install

Shingle Roof

Singles are the most common roofing material among most homeowners. They are available in a wide range of materials such as slate, plastic, composites, etc. However, the most common shingles are made out of asphalt. They provide countless benefits. Here are the pros and cons of the shingle roofing. 

  • Affordable
  • Easy to install
  • Low-maintenance
  • Versatile
  • Better for most climates
  • Enhance resale value
  • Not durable
  • Not long-lasting
  • Fever style choices
  • Not eco-friendly 
Tile vs Shingle-The Difference

If you are unable to choose between shingle and tile, here is the detailed difference between these two roofing materials. Ensure one of the best residential roofing companies in Laredo Tx to get the roof installation. 

  • Appearance

When it comes to the asphalt shingle roof’s appearance, it is made of flexible shingles that are installed overlapping each other. However, thicker shingles have been developed that add more structure dimension to your roof and mimic slate material. Besides, shingles are available in different colors, and they may have some texture, or they may appear more flat depending on the brand and style you choose. 

While on the other hand, tiles are versatile. Tiles are available in different materials, including concrete, clay, and metal, available in a wide range of patterns, colors, and shapes. You can create a unique and personalized look for your home with a tile roof rather than choosing a different color or thicker shingle. 

  • Installation

Asphalt shingles are easy to install as most shingles have tabs that easily overlap one another. They are nailed down and then sealed. Only a felt underlayment is required under them as long as the roof deck is in good condition.

While tiles require roof strengthening first, it is because of the weight of the tiles involved. However, tiles also need underlayment, but the installation process is slower and more involved. Some tiles and patterns are faster to install, such as interlocking tiles that almost snap into the right place. While traditional S, ridge, and scallop patterns must be cemented one at a time. It can take several days, depending on the roof size. 

  • Cost

Shingles are more affordable than the tile roofing. Every type of roofing is sold and installed by the square i.e., 100 square feet. The national average cost of an asphalt shingle roofing is between $65 and $80. The installation cost is around $50 per square feet. However, the additional cost includes $1000 for tearing off the old roof and $400 for supplies and felt. Thus, the average cost of a 1500 square foot roof will be between $3125 and $3350.

On the other hand, the tile roof is higher with the material costing $120 to $250 per square feet. Tearing off the old roof is similar to shingles as $1000 while reinforcing the roof to hold the tile’s weight will cost between $1000 and $10000, and the labor cost is $465 to $665. The total average cost of 1500 square foot tile will cost $11300 to $25325. 

  • Weight

An asphalt shingle roof is light in weight and can be easily installed on any type of roof. However, tiles can be very heavy, depending on the material you choose. Every tile roof is heavier than the shingle roof and requires some degree of roof reinforcement. If you are unable to reinforce the roof or your home cannot support a heavy roof, a shingle roof is best installed by one of the best top leading residential roofing companies in Laredo Tx. Make sure you are choosing the right company for the installation to ensure top-quality results. 

  • Climate

An asphalt roof can handle all types of climates. However, tiles are mostly installed in the southern parts because the clay tiles might not be able to handle freeze or thaw conditions. But the metal tiles can be installed anywhere. Tile roofs may have a short lifespan in the dry and hot climate due to the heat. However, heat can shorten the lifespan of shingles as well. So, it is essential that you hire one of the residential roofing companies in Laredo Tx and ask the professionals which material is best suited in your area. 

  • Durability

When it comes to durability, tiles can last way longer than the shingle roofs. Depending on the tile material, it can last between 25 and 100 years if maintained properly. Metal tiles tend to last the longest. However, there are clay tiles that are over 100 years old as well. On the other hand, asphalt shingles last from 15 to 30 years, depending on the type, thickness, and style. The architectural and thicker shingle roofs can last longer than the traditional one. 

  • Maintenance

In terms of maintenance, both roofing types are relatively the same. Both roofs should be inspected regularly for cracked, broken, or missing tiles and shingles. If the inspection report shows any moss growth, it should be cleaned carefully. However, if your roof has clay tiles, avoid walking on it as it is risky and cause the tile to break. Besides, if a broken shingle or tile is found, make sure to replace it as soon as possible to avoid further damage to your roof. 

  • Resale Value

A new roof installation always adds value to your home. Due to the longevity or the tile roof, it may be more appealing to the new home buyers. However, a new roof is usually considered a significant investment in the home, and it automatically increases the resale value of the house.